The big lie and a right to a fair trial

NZ$42.00

At Oscar Pistorius’ bail application, the prosecution asserted that there had been an hour-long argument, non-stop fighting and loud talking between Oscar and Reeva before the shots that so tragically ended Reeva’s life. The prosecution pursued that assertion as the truth during the trial. What if there was no evidence to support that scenario?

The prosecution further pursued that assertion during the five days of Oscar’s cross-examination. There are legal, procedural and ethical boundaries limiting what a prosecution is permitted to do when cross-examining an accused. What if those boundaries were exceeded during Oscar’s trial? And what if his evidence about his state of mind was undermined by impermissible cross-examination, resulting in the Supreme Court of Appeal upgrading his conviction to murder?

What if the Supreme Court of Appeal committed a string of errors of fact, logic and law in convicting Oscar of murder? Were the country’s foremost criminal law professors right when they disagreed with the murder verdict?

Finally, what was the Big Lie in the title of the book?

The answers to these troubling questions are given by Chris Marnewick SC, an experienced senior advocate, author and educator, after an extensive analysis of the record of the trial, the evidence given by the witnesses, the judgments of the courts, and the legal principles applying to a criminal trial.

Published: Sept 2026

Format: Paperback

Pages: 336

At Oscar Pistorius’ bail application, the prosecution asserted that there had been an hour-long argument, non-stop fighting and loud talking between Oscar and Reeva before the shots that so tragically ended Reeva’s life. The prosecution pursued that assertion as the truth during the trial. What if there was no evidence to support that scenario?

The prosecution further pursued that assertion during the five days of Oscar’s cross-examination. There are legal, procedural and ethical boundaries limiting what a prosecution is permitted to do when cross-examining an accused. What if those boundaries were exceeded during Oscar’s trial? And what if his evidence about his state of mind was undermined by impermissible cross-examination, resulting in the Supreme Court of Appeal upgrading his conviction to murder?

What if the Supreme Court of Appeal committed a string of errors of fact, logic and law in convicting Oscar of murder? Were the country’s foremost criminal law professors right when they disagreed with the murder verdict?

Finally, what was the Big Lie in the title of the book?

The answers to these troubling questions are given by Chris Marnewick SC, an experienced senior advocate, author and educator, after an extensive analysis of the record of the trial, the evidence given by the witnesses, the judgments of the courts, and the legal principles applying to a criminal trial.

Published: Sept 2026

Format: Paperback

Pages: 336

Moord op Stellenbosch - Julian Jansen
Language::

Die moord op twee pragmeisies in hul skoolkoshuis vroeg op ’n wintersoggend in 2018 het die hegte boeregemeenskap van Stella in Noordwes onherroeplik getraumatiseer. Die ysingwekkende feite van die saak het trouens die hele Suid-Afrika geruk. Xander Bylsma (19), ’n aantreklike boerseun van die omgewing, is aangekla van die wrede wurgmoorde op die sprankelende Sharnelle Hough en Marna Engelbrecht, ’n skrander donkerkop. Watter intriges het tot die moord gelei? En hoe leef die gesinne van drie belowende en geliefde jong mense met die gevolge van ’n grudaad in ’n gemeenskap van vervlegte lewens? Susan Cilliers, skrywer van die topverkoper Huis van Gruwels, skryf indringend oor die vrae wat ná die hofsaak onbeantwoord bly, oor lewens vernietig in hul fleur en oor die moontlikheid van berusting en vergifnis.